POLITICS

5 Errors In Sonia Memoir & Slipper Fury At DK Shivakumar VIP Darshan

ThePrint double header Nov 15 — Sonia Gandhi's Belonging memoir flagged for 5 factual errors from Rahul term to RSS founding, plus DKS Hasanamba temple VIP puja sparks slipper protest

Cult Current Desk
Cult Current Desk
16 Nov 2026
Solar farm during sunset

PART 1 — 5 errors in Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging: A Journey of Love:

Book released Nov 10, 544 pages — India Today audit found 55 errors, ThePrint lists 5 key.

1. Rahul Gandhi term: Gandhi writes (p493) Rahul is "four-term MP". He became five-term after Rae Bareli win 2024 — elected 2004, 2009, 2014, 2019, 2024.

2. Chidambaram-Mukherjee swap: Recounting 2010 differences, she refers to Chidambaram as Finance Minister and Mukherjee hinting change at top — actually in 2010 Mukherjee was FM, Chidambaram Home Minister. Chidambaram returned to Finance only July 2012 after Mukherjee resigned for President poll.

3. 1984 poll figures: Writes Congress won "405 seats out of 544" (p270) after Indira assassination. Actual: 404 seats (later 415 with Assam/Punjab delayed polls) for 542 seats contested. In another passage she gives 404 — inconsistency.

4. RSS founding: Describes RSS as "founded in 1921" (p342) — founded Sept 27, 1925 Nagpur by K B Hedgewar.

5. Ahmed Patel death: Writes he "fell victim to Covid epidemic in 2022" (p399) — died Nov 25, 2020 following Covid complications.

Other flagged errors in wider audit: Kargil timeline — says Vajpayee hosted by Nawaz in Islamabad when shepherd Tashi Namgyal spotted intruders — Vajpayee was in Lahore Feb 20-21, 1999, spotting May 3; says 10 months to recapture — war ended July 1999; Vajpayee govt fall April 1999 called no-confidence — actually confidence motion lost 269-270 by 1 vote; Rahul defamation — says Gujarat High Court sentenced 2 years 2023 — actually Surat magistrate court March 23, 2023, remarks April 2019 Kolar; Anna Hazare face in 2012 not April 5, 2011 Jantar Mantar; Gujarat capital as Ahmedabad not Gandhinagar (capital since 1970); Sabarmati Express four coaches burnt not S-6 only where 59 died; NDA 2014 353 seats instead of 336; Nelson Mandela Bharat Ratna 1991 not Oct 1990; KR Narayanan as President not Vice-President at Mandela inauguration 1994.

PART 2 — Shivakumar VIP darshan sparks anger, footwear flies:

Karnataka Dy CM/CM-designate D K Shivakumar faced public ire over VIP darshan at Hasanamba festival Hassan Nov 8 Sunday Deepavali.

Temple opens only once a year limited period — lakhs queue. Shivakumar with wife Usha entered sanctum sanctorum around noon for special puja, general darshan queue temporarily stopped — hours wait for devotees, many women.

Worse — large LED screens near queue projected Shivakumar family receiving uninterrupted darshan.

Woman heard screaming: “The Chief Minister should do good for others. That's why he is CM, not by troubling others. Only he needs God.”

Others hurled footwear at screen displaying puja — video viral Nov 9-10. Outside crowd chided him over price hikes milk, bus fares.

Karnataka BJP post X: “This is what happened just by seeing him on the screen... Imagine what would happen if they encountered him in person!”

CMO sources to India Today alleged political conspiracy — claimed JD(S) workers staged footwear throw and circulated video, not devotees.

Hasanamba shrine has three temples Darbar Ganapati, Hasanamba, Siddeshwara — Shivakumar also inaugurated flower-fruit show and sports festival.

 

#SoniaGandhi #Belonging #DKShivakumar #HasanambaTemple #VIPDarshan #MemoirErrors #Karnataka #Congress #FactCheck #ThePrint