NEW DELHI: Cauvery River Dispute: Supreme Court Dismisses Tamil Nadu's Applications Seeking Additional Water... Supreme Court Friday dismissed two pleas Tamil Nadu government seeking direction Karnataka release 11 thousand million cubic TMC feet Cauvery river water.
Bench Justices Vikram Nath Aparesh Kumar Singh said Tamil Nadu filed third application bringing record some additional documents which also dismissed.
In pleas Tamil Nadu government sought directions Karnataka make sure backlog 11 TMC Cauvery water Oct 7 cleared immediately ensure same rate 1.3 TMC per day 10 days Billigundulu key water-measuring station banks river along Karnataka-Tamil Nadu border.
Oct 12 top court reserved decision two applications Tamil Nadu government.
Bench rebuke:
Justice Nath pronouncing order: "Application dismissed. You filed another application today. It looks like State Tamil Nadu has lots money waste lawyers. We dismissed this application will also dismiss other application," said Justice Nath reading operative part order.
No detailed reasoning yet — operative order only. Full judgment expected later? Dismissal means TN cannot get SC order forcing release backlog.
TN case:
Tamil Nadu contended shortfall 11.719 tmcft flows due Billigundulu inter-State border measuring point up Oct 6.
Tamil Nadu moved SC seeking implementation Cauvery Water Management Authority CWMA directions requiring Karnataka release water State amid allegations not receiving stipulated share river water.
State grievance centres water-sharing arrangement Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal award under which TN claims annual entitlement 64 TMC? Actually SC formula Karnataka required release 177.25 TMC TN normal water year — senior counsel Mukul Rohatgi submitted Karnataka owed TN 11 TMC since July needed release outstanding quantity protect standing crops. Also sought release additional 1 TMC water per day make up shortfall.
TN accused Karnataka withholding water despite sufficient reserves pointing combined reservoir storage ∼49 tmcft maintained adequate meet water-sharing obligations lower riparian State.
TN alleged Karnataka failed release state due share Cauvery water year violation SC earlier judgment.
TN also sought immediate release 3,500 cusecs water day 15 days Kabini Krishna Raja Sagara reservoirs Karnataka — per Bar Bench version earlier application.
Karnataka case:
Karnataka opposed application ground CWMA had not ordered it. Maintaining complying directions CWMA.
Karnataka said TN formula wrong, flows measured Billigundulu include natural flows, Karnataka releases as per CWMA monthly schedule, not TN's 11.719 calculation. Reservoirs need drinking water Bengaluru Mysuru, farmers Mandya, not surplus.
Karnataka CM D.K. Shivakumar Fri Nov 20 said State would provide Cauvery water Tamil Nadu if sufficient water available State. "If we have water we will give it Tamil Nadu," Shivakumar responding question Cauvery water-sharing issue.
President Karnataka Sugarcane Growers Association Kurubur Shanthakumar welcomed SC decision dismiss TN petition seeking release Cauvery river water Fri Nov 20.
History:
Cauvery dispute origins agreements 1892 1924 erstwhile Madras Presidency princely Mysore.
Long-standing dispute started 1974 Karnataka upper riparian started diverting water without TN consent.
Tribunal 2007: Karnataka 270 TMC, TN 419 TMC, Kerala 30, Puducherry 7. SC 2018 modified: Karnataka 284.75, TN 404.25, Kerala 30, Puducherry 7, environment 10. Karnataka release 177.25 TMC TN normal year at Billigundulu monthly schedule.
CWMA + Cauvery Water Regulation Committee CWRC created 2018 implement.
2023 SC declined entertain TN plea seeking increase daily Cauvery allocation 5,000 cusecs 7,200 cusecs.
Every monsoon deficit year — TN files, Karnataka resists, SC / CWMA intervenes, protests Mandya Thanjavur, bandhs.
What next:
Dismissal not end dispute — TN can go CWMA, CWRC, file fresh if new shortfall, seek review? SC dismissal applications — not main suit. Main Cauvery suit disposed 2018.
Farmers Thanjavur delta: samba paddy standing crop needs water Nov-Dec. If Karnataka doesn't release, crop loss. TN govt says will approach CWMA again, monitor Billigundulu flows daily.
Karnataka farmers Mandya: need water sugarcane, drinking Bengaluru — 49 TMC storage not surplus, monsoon weak Oct, KRS Kabini levels falling.
Political: TN CM M.K. Stalin faces 2026 assembly election Apr-May — Cauvery emotional issue. Karnataka CM Shivakumar faces BJP pressure Mandya — cannot be seen giving water TN.
SC rebuke "lots money waste lawyers" — signal courts tired repeated interlocutory applications, want CWMA decide technical water sharing, not SC every week.
TN water minister Duraimurugan: respect verdict, will continue legal fight, approach CWMA.
#Cauvery #SupremeCourt #TamilNadu #Karnataka #Billigundulu #CWMA #Water #Stalin #Shivakumar #Thanjavur