POLITICS

MEA Says Indus Waters Treaty Stance Unchanged As Pakistan Minister Attends SCO Forum In Delhi

Delhi Nov 20 — MEA Randhir Jaiswal: IWT position "very clear, absolutely no change". Pak Climate Minister Musadik Malik arrived early Fri, attended Purana Quila forum inaugurated Modi. First Pak minister visit since Op Sindoor May 2025.

Cult Current Desk
Cult Current Desk
21 Nov 2026
Solar farm during sunset

 

NEW DELHI: MEA says Indus Waters Treaty stance unchanged Pakistan minister attends SCO forum Delhi. India position Indus Waters Treaty IWT "very clear" "absolutely no change" Ministry External Affairs said Fri Nov 20 2026 amid visit Pakistan Minister Musadik Malik attend SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum Delhi.

Malik arrived early hours Fri Nov 20 attended opening day three-day forum evening. Event hosted India historic Purana Quila inaugurated PM Narendra Modi.

India announced Oct 28 invitations extended all SCO members including Pakistan keeping established practice.

Perhaps first time New Delhi invited Pakistani minister attend event India since May 7-10 military hostilities last year following Operation Sindoor.

Pakistan announced Nov 14 Climate Change Minister Malik participate forum. At bi-weekly media briefing MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal asked how New Delhi viewed Malik participation India-hosted forum given does not hold culture portfolio reportedly made comments IWT.

"As far IWT concerned we made position very clear that where remains. Absolutely no change," Jaiswal said.

India suspended treaty 2025 one punitive measures Pakistan after April 22 Pahalgam terror attack last year claimed 26 lives.

Malik participation forum seen some experts opportunity multilateral framework may help improve ties two neighbours.

Interacting reporters sidelines forum Malik when asked role culture fostering better ties India Pakistan said "Culture very key role play".

Hours before inauguration MEA Fri said forum "multilateral event within SCO framework" invitations extended all members grouping including Pakistan.

"India hosting 1st SCO Civilisation Dialogue 20-22 Nov 2026 New Delhi. Multilateral event within SCO framework invitations extended all members SCO including Pakistan," MEA said post X.

“Observers Dialogue Partners SCO also invited attend Dialogue inaugurated evening Hon'ble Prime Minister,”

Event hosted Ministry Culture MEA.

SCO founded summit Shanghai 2001 presidents Russia, China, Kyrgyz Republic, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan Uzbekistan. India Pakistan became permanent members 2017.

Why Malik? Why now?

Malik is NOT culture minister — he's Climate Change + Water Resources? In Pakistan, Malik holds Climate Change, also previously Water Resources, Petroleum. He reportedly made comments IWT — Pakistan says India suspension illegal, water weapon, will go Hague / World Bank arbitration.

Delhi chose him? Pakistan chose him deliberately — signal: We want talk water, climate, not culture. Islamabad: Send water minister to water-hostile Delhi, test thaw.

India response: No bilateral meeting. No Jaishankar-Malik meeting scheduled. No sideline talks. Only multilateral forum, photo-op, no handshake beyond protocol.

MEA pre-empted: Forum multilateral, NOT bilateral thaw. IWT unchanged.

Malik fumbles terrorism question:

Speaking reporters sidelines forum Malik when asked India concerns cross-border terrorism said “I think tomorrow once give my statement we'll have lot conversations...”

Instead directly addressing question Pakistani minister highlighted importance dialogue countries region describing SCO forum welcome initiative amid changing geopolitical dynamics.

"It's wonderful have dialogue across civilisations entire region. Geopolitics flux. Easy speak things like this. Very welcome sign," Malik said.

Minister also expressed optimism future India-Pakistan relations saying hoped countries region adopt broader approach addressing shared political social challenges.

When asked whether India-Pakistan relations could improve following SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum Malik expressed hope ties across region move positive direction.

Tomorrow Sat — Malik statement at forum — will he raise IWT? Kashmir? Terror? Delhi watching.

What is IWT suspension — status 19 months on:

IWT 1960 World Bank brokered — India gets eastern rivers Ravi, Beas, Sutlej; Pakistan western Indus, Jhelum, Chenab — 80% water Pakistan. India can use western for run-of-river hydro, limited irrigation, no storage.

Apr 23 2025: India put treaty "in abeyance" after Pahalgam — Cabinet Committee Security: “Treaty held abeyance until Pakistan credibly irrevocably abjures support cross-border terrorism.”

Meaning: India no longer bound share flow data, no Permanent Indus Commission meetings, no prior notification dams, can build storage / divert? India says: We will use our rights, build Kishanganga, Ratle, Pakal Dul, Kiru, Kwar — 10,000 MW J&K — without Pakistan objection process.

Pakistan: Approached World Bank, Hague Court Arbitration 2025 — Court said IWT still in force, India must comply. India rejected: Court has no jurisdiction after suspension, Pakistan-sponsored terror…

On ground: India hasn't stopped water — Chenab, Jhelum flow continues — monsoon floods 2025 Pakistan blamed India releasing water without warning. India: No treaty, no obligation warn. Pakistan floods killed 1,000+ Aug 2025 — water politics deadly.

Pakistan agriculture 90% Indus — 240M people — if India builds storage 10 BCM, Pakistan dry season hit.

India position: Suspension reversible ONLY if Pakistan stops terror, extradites Pahalgam masterminds, dismantles LeT / JeM. No talks until then.

SCO Forum — what is it?

1st SCO Civilisation Dialogue Nov 20-22 Purana Quila — India SCO chair? India hosting culture dialogue — delegates China, Russia, Iran, Central Asia, Pakistan, observers Mongolia, Belarus, etc.

Themes: Shared heritage, Silk Road, Buddhism, Sufism, yoga, language, food.

Modi inaugurated Fri evening: "Civilisations don't clash, they converse" — India Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, SCO diversity.

No joint statement expected — culture only.

Experts: Thaw or trap?

Some experts: Multilateral engagement can thaw — like Jaishankar went Islamabad SCO Oct 2024, first FM visit 9 yrs, no bilateral but ice broke. Malik visit similar — first Pak minister Delhi since Sindoor.

Others: Pakistan using SCO to internationalise IWT, get China / Russia pressure India restore treaty. China also upstream Brahmaputra — India doesn't want precedent.

Delhi line: Culture ≠ politics. No bilateral = no concession.

What next Sat-Sun:

- Malik statement Sat — if raises IWT / Kashmir, India will rebut

- No bilateral meeting — Malik returns Sun night

- SCO forum ends Sun — declaration culture cooperation

- IWT: India continues dams J&K, no data sharing

- Pakistan: May go UN? World Bank again?

First step back — not peace, but protocol.

 

#IndusWatersTreaty #MEA #Pakistan #SCO #MusadikMalik #Delhi #Modi #Pahalgam #OperationSindoor #Water