The Story So Far:
Italy data protection authority Garante fined Meta Platforms €805 million ($880-887M) Saturday Nov 14 2026 for accessing photos and videos from Android users galleries without specific consent. Largest fine ever imposed by Italian authority on tech company — about 0.4-0.47% of annual global revenue — Meta 2025 revenue $201B profit $60.5B.
This is not GDPR but ePrivacy route. Separate from New Mexico $25B fine Oct for Cambridge Analytica deception.
What was the feature?
Facebook offers "Get tips / suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook" — since 2023. While you scroll feed, suggests photos/videos from phone gallery as post ideas.
Example: you took beach photo, Facebook suggests “Post this?”
Complaint from consumer protection forum in Bolzano said platform accessed "unpublished files stored on users smartphones".
How consent violated?
Garante technical analysis found:
- Facebook requested access to phone gallery through single app-wide authorisation valid for various other functions as well — preceded by generic notice "enable other features" — did not make clear you were also authorising gallery suggestions.
- Suggestions option enabled by default — on until you find toggle.
- Such authorisation allowed platform to read entire phone gallery ongoing basis, plus metadata.
- Neither user nor regulator can see exactly which data app accesses or uses.
Investigation began 2025. Scope did NOT include whether data used to train AI models — Meta denies AI training use. But Garante reserved right to separately assess new 2026 feature that allows gallery content processed in cloud.
Legal basis:
Violated Article 122 Italy Privacy Code which implements EU ePrivacy rules on access to information stored on devices. Under ePrivacy, smartphone is part of private sphere — any access to data stored on it requires free and informed consent, whether data leaves device or harm.
Important route: Under GDPR Meta EU base Ireland — lead authority Irish DPC. Under ePrivacy, no lead authority mechanism — Garante rejected Meta argument that Irish authority should handle. So fine directly by Italy. March 2026 Rome court annulled Garante €15M GDPR fine against OpenAI for same reason — ePrivacy route now preferred.
What Garante ordered?
- Switch off feature by default, even for users who already gave consent, within 60 days.
- Must request consent for feature through specific and separate request, clearly explain what it is for, that it involves access to gallery, and how to disable.
- In calculating fine: large number affected — around 20M Android users Italy, duration infringement ongoing for those who not updated app and those already granted permission, lack of cooperation from Meta during investigation, prior violation fine 2019.
Meta response:
Spokesperson: strongly disagree, call fine disproportionate, will appeal.
Impact: €805M = ∼2% of Meta 2025 free cash flow $43.59B — less than tenth of $9.9B legal charge booked Q3 for Aug 2026 multi-state settlement. Real risk precedent — other EU regulators could bring similar cases under own ePrivacy implementations — Europe ∼23% of Meta revenue.
#Meta #Italy #Garante #ePrivacy #Fine #Facebook #Android #DataProtection #GallerySuggestions #GDPR