New Delhi: Cash-strapped Indian states risk derailing Prime Minister Modi infrastructure push as rising spending commitments and weaker revenues leave less for asset creation, studies said.
Key findings:
1. Debt tripled:
CAG Decadal Analysis State Finances 2023-24 — first long-term comparative — presented by CAG K. Sanjay Murthy: Combined public debt 28 states from Rs 17.57 lakh crore in 2013-14 to Rs 59.60 lakh crore in 2022-23 — almost triple — as % of GSDP 16.66% to 22.96% — now larger than GDP of many economies. RBI estimates combined debt 29.2% GDP by March 2026.
Highest burden: Punjab 40.35% GSDP, Nagaland 37.15%, West Bengal 33.70%. 8 states >30%, 14 states 20-30%, only 6 <20% — Odisha 8.45%, Maharashtra 14.64%, Gujarat 16.37% lowest.
2. Spending skewed to revenue:
CAG: Revenue expenditure 83.25% total, capex only 16.75% — Rs 38.96 lakh cr vs Rs 7.84 lakh cr. Nearly 60% budgets committed — salaries, pensions, interest. RECO ratio — revenue exp to capital outlay — exceeds 10 in Delhi, Punjab, Kerala, Puducherry — means Rs 10 day-to-day for every Re 1 building.
RBI Report State Budgets 2025-26: States with interest payments >15% revenue receipts spend <2% GSDP on capex vs national average. Market borrowing rose 21% YoY H1.
Violation of Golden Rule — borrowings diverted for current expenditure in 11 states — debt trap risk.
3. Subsidy explosion:
PRS State of State Finance 2026-27: Subsidies + cash transfers rose from 16% revenue receipts 2018-19 to 21% 2023-24 — subsidies CAGR 12%, transfers 24%. States to spend ∼1% GDP Rs 4 lakh crore on cash transfer schemes 2026-27 vs 0.6% 2022-23. Nine states including West Bengal, AP, Telangana spend >10% revenue on unconditional transfers — Jharkhand, West Bengal 10-11% on women schemes alone. Power subsidies + unconditional largest shares.
RBI: Farm loan waiver, free electricity, free transport, unemployment allowance, cash to women — welfare-heavy Tamil Nadu, West Bengal — politically necessary but fiscally risky.
But silver lining:
Crisil Ratings Nov 6 analysis 18 states 90% GSDP: Capital outlay set to accelerate to Rs 8.5 lakh crore this fiscal FY27 vs Rs 7.6 lakh crore last — growth 10-12%, outpacing 8.6% last fiscal. States expected to achieve 84% budgeted capex vs 82% last, average 85% 5-yr.
Driver: Special Assistance to States for Capital Investment SASCI — 50-yr interest-free loans outside normal borrowing limits — allocation up 33% to Rs 2 lakh crore this fiscal vs Rs 1.54 lakh crore RE FY26. Higher SASCI gives room without drawing normal limits — Anuj Sethi, Crisil. Urban infrastructure WSS-H-UD high double-digit growth, transport ∼25% largest segment high single-digit.
Risk: SASCI disbursements only 25% by Sept, execution depends timely release, rising rates, deficient monsoon, persistent inflation 6.09% CPI, 12.29% WPI.
Nov 17: Squeeze between commitments and weaker revenues leaving less infra exactly when Modi counting investment sustain rapid growth.
#IndianStates #StateDebt #Infrastructure #CAG #RBI #Crisil #SASCI #FiscalStress #Subsidies #Capex