SCIENCE

APTEL: Wind Beyond 23% CUF Must Get Full Tariff

New Delhi Nov 17 — APTEL kills APERC ₹0.50/unit cap in 23 appeals — normative CUF is tariff benchmark, not payment ceiling — APSPDCL must pay full ₹4.70 + interest for all units.

Cult Current Desk
Cult Current Desk
19 Nov 2026
Solar farm during sunset

 

NEW DELHI: Appellate Tribunal Electricity APTEL ruled favour wind power generators batch 23 appeals challenging orders passed Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission APERC. Judgment pronounced Nov 17 2026 tribunal set aside APERC directions restricting payments wind energy generated beyond normative Capacity Utilisation Factor CUF. Held generators entitled receive applicable agreed tariff all electricity supplied distribution companies irrespective whether annual generation exceeds normative CUF.

Dispute involved Power Purchase Agreements PPAs signed wind generators Southern Power Distribution Company Andhra Pradesh Limited APSPDCL. Under APERC tariff orders generic tariffs determined based normative CUF. For instance Nov 15 2012 order fixed tariff ₹4.70 per unit based normative CUF 23% for 25 years Commercial Operation Date.

However through several orders issued Sept 2022 July 2024 APERC treated normative CUF payment limit. Directed electricity generated beyond benchmark receive only ₹0.50 per unit along provisions cumulative annual CUF adjustments.

Bench reasoning:

APTEL bench Judicial Member Virender Bhat Technical Member Ajay Talegaonkar examined whether APERC authority introduce different payment arrangements electricity generated beyond normative CUF.

Tribunal clarified normative CUF annual benchmark used calculating fixed costs determining generic tariffs. Since wind generation depends changing weather conditions actual electricity output can vary significantly year year. Therefore normative CUF cannot treated separate billing limit used divide electricity regular excess generation.

APTEL also observed PPAs did not contain provision restricting payments electricity generated within normative CUF. Agreements specified monthly limits based contracted export capacity operating hours rather annual generation cap.

Tribunal further noted wind developers already bear risks associated lower wind availability generation shortfalls. If they bear downside low wind, they must get upside high wind.

Accordingly APTEL set aside ₹0.50 per unit payment provision cumulative CUF adjustment directions. Directed all delivered electricity must paid applicable generic tariff under respective PPAs. Tribunal also rejected APSPDCL request remanding matter APERC ordered payment withheld amounts along applicable interest under agreements.

Beta Wind Farm case:

Beta signed 25-year PPA APSPDCL May 29 2013 tariff ₹4.70 per unit determined APERC. 50.4 MW wind project Andhra Pradesh.

APSPDCL withheld ₹5.93 crore for 1,26,17,939 units electricity supplied July 27 2016 July 27 2017 treating generation exceeding 23% CUF benchmark. APERC Sept 26 2022 order allowed only ₹0.50 per unit beyond benchmark applied cumulative CUF calculation. APTEL set aside both.

Company estimates ₹12.98 crore receivables:

- Withheld principal ₹5.93 crore

- Interest claimed up March 2022 ₹3.09 crore

- Interest April 2022 Oct 2026 ₹3.96 crore

Total estimated receivable ₹12.98 crore subject actual implementation order. Payment not yet confirmed received.

Beta operates 241.6 MW wind projects Tamil Nadu Andhra Pradesh Gujarat Karnataka. Orient Green Power Company Limited NSE GREENPOWER BSE 533263 said favourable ruling provides clarity treatment electricity generated beyond normative CUF PPA.

Shares gained Thursday Nov 19 after subsidiary win.

JSW also wins:

JSW Energy subsidiaries JSW Vayu Tungabhadra, JSW Vayu Indravati, JSW Wind Power Pennar, JSW Wind Power Limited also filed appeals against APERC order Oct 18 2023. APTEL Nov 17 allowed appeal set aside APERC order directed AP Discoms pay energy generated wind generators applicable generic tariff irrespective actual generation exceeds normative CUF mandated payment applicable interest respective PPAs.

Why matters:. 

AP discoms long tried renegotiate old high tariffs ₹4.70-₹5.50 wind solar PPAs signed 2012-15 when costs high. Now new wind tariffs ₹2.80-₹3.20. Paying ₹0.50 for excess was effectively confiscating free power — discom gets energy sells consumers ₹6-7 pays generator 50 paise.

APTEL precedent protects sanctity PPA across India. Similar disputes Tamil Nadu Karnataka Gujarat Maharashtra where regulators tried cap CUF. Developers can now claim full tariff excess generation, improve cash flow, bankability.

But order not cash yet. APSPDCL can appeal Supreme Court. Investors distinguish potential recovery recurring operating performance because does not itself demonstrate higher generation improved margins additional capacity.

APSPDCL must comply pay withheld + interest PPA rate. If appeals, Supreme Court likely uphold PPA sanctity — earlier 2020 Andhra PPA renegotiation attempt struck down.

Wind developers: excess wind no longer free for discom.

 

#APTEL #WindPower #APERC #APSPDCL #CUF #PPA #Tariff #OrientGreen #JSWEnergy #Renewable